Table of contents for Exploring information superiority : a methodology for measuring the quality of information and its impact on shared awareness / Walter Perry, David Signori, John Boon.


Bibliographic record and links to related information available from the Library of Congress catalog. Note: Contents data are machine generated based on pre-publication information provided by the publisher. Contents may have variations from the printed book or be incomplete or contain other coding.


Counter
CONTENTS
Preface	iii
Figures	xi
Tables	xiii
Summary	xv
Introduction	xv
The Analytic Framework	xvi
The Physical and Information Domains	xix
Sensor Metrics	xix
Fusion Metrics	xx
Network Metrics	xxi
The Cognitive Domain	xxiii
Modeling Individual Situational Awareness	xxiii
Modeling Shared Situational Awareness	xxiv
Future Directions	xxvi
Acknowledgements	xxix
Glossary of Terms and Acronyms	xxxi
Chapter 1. Introduction	1
Research Objectives	2
Analytical Framework	3
Limitations	4
Organization of this Report	4
Chapter 2. The Analytic Framework	7
The C4ISR Information Superiority Reference Model	7
The C4ISR Architecture	9
The Network-Centric Warfare Value Chain	10
Information Quality	13
Fitness Measure	14
Completeness	15
Correctness	15
Currency	16
A Quantitative Methodology	16
Summing up	18
Chapter 3: The Physical and Information Domains	21
The Physical Domain	21
Features	21
The Relevant Ground Truth	22
The Information Domain	22
The Sensor Sub-Domain	23
Sensors and sources	24
Active and Passive Sensors	24
Sensor Detections	25
Completeness	25
Correctness	27
Currency	31
The Fusion Sub-Domain	31
Fusion	32
Uses of Fused Information	33
Fusion Facilities	34
Automation and Control	35
Completeness	35
Correctness	37
Currency	41
The Network Sub-Domain	41
Communications Networks	42
Completeness	42
Correctness	43
Currency	44
An Alternative for Complete Networks	45
Shared Information	46
Summing Up	47
Sensor Metrics	47
Fusion Metrics	48
Network Metrics	49
Chapter 4. The Cognitive Domain	51
Analysis in the Cognitive Domain	52
Modeling Individual Situational Awareness	53
Modeling the Individual	53
Individual Situational Awareness	55
The Impact of Fusion Levels	56
Modeling Shared Situational Awareness	57
Collaborating Teams	58
Common Ground	60
Collaboration and Common Ground	61
Transactive Memory Systems	62
Structure and Contents of the Transactive Memory System	63
Process Model for Development of the Transactive Memory System	65
Modeling Familiarity	67
Estimating Team Hardness	68
Consensus	69
Shared Situational Awareness	70
Summing up	72
Modeling Individual Situational Awareness	72
Modeling Shared Situational Awareness	73
Implications	75
Chapter 5. Future Work	77
Refinement of Current Research	77
Data Fitting	77
Experimentation	78
Decision, Understanding and Action	78
Historical Analyses	78
Gaming	79
Application of the Research to Other C4ISR Architectures	79
Appendix A. Some Definitions	81
Measures and Metrics	81
Information	82
Information Superiority	84
Network Centric Warfare	84
Cognitive Domain Terms	87
Appendix B. Candidate Models	89
Similarity Matrices	89
Armor	90
Set Theoretic Tracking Metric	91
Critical Path Method	92
Sensors	94
A Reliability Model of Completeness	95
Occlusions	97
Collective Completeness	99
Dissemination	101
Individual Situational Awareness	103
Transactive Memory System Model	105
A Revised Model of Individual Situational Awareness	107
A Model of Shared Situational Awareness	107
Appendix C. A Spreadsheet Model Representation	109
Modelling Information Quality	109
Sensors	109
Fusion	111
Network	112
Modeling Team Decision Making	112
The Graphical User Interfaces (GUI)	113
Information Domain Assessments	113
Cognitive Domain Assessments	115
Analysis	116
Results	119
References	121
FIGURES
Fig. S.1 / The Information Superiority Reference Model	xvii
Fig. S.2 / The Information Superiority Value Chain	xviii
Fig. 2.1 / The Information Superiority Reference Model	9
Fig. 2.2 / The Information Superiority Value Chain	11
Fig. 3.1 / Information Domain Transformations	23
Fig. 3.2 / Measuring Precision	30
Fig. 3.3 / Parallel-Sequential Fusion Process	34
Fig. 3.4 / Fusion Center Classification Rates	36
Fig. 3.5 / Basic Elements of a Recursive Tracking System	39
Fig. 3.6 / Tracking Cases when n=k	40
Fig. 3.7 / Tracking Cases when n > k	41
Fig. 3.8 / Shared and Common Information	47
Fig. 4.1 / Cognitive Domain Transformations	52
Fig. 4.2 / Notional Effect of Complete Information on Awareness	56
Fig. 4.3 / Fusion Level Effects on Situational Awareness	57
Fig. 4.4 / Transactive Memory System for Shared Situational Awareness	64
Fig. 4.5 / Process Model for Developing the Transactive Memory System	66
Fig. 4.6 / Collaborative Team Development	68
Fig. 4.7 / Team Size and Hardness Determine Task Duration	75
Fig. B.1 / Track Sets	92
Fig. B.2 / Example Currency Calculation	93
Fig. B.3 / Generic Sensor Performance Model	95
Fig. B.4 / Sensor Performance	97
Fig. B.5 / Terrain Occluded Targets	98
Fig. B.6 / Accounting for Occlusions	99
Fig. B.7 / Multi-Sensor Operations	100
Fig. B.8 / A Communications Sub-Network	102
Fig. B.9 / The Effect of Complete Information on Awareness	104
Fig. B.10 / S-Curve Representation of Quality Effects on Situational Awareness	105
Fig. B.11 / Transactive Memory for Alternative Values of Team Hardness	106
Fig. C.1 / Alternative Sensor Architectures	111
Fig. C.2 / Model Fusion Architecture	112
Fig. C.3 / Infoview Information Domain GUI	114
Fig. C.4 / Infoview Cognitive Domain GUI	116
Fig. C.5 / Mixed Architecture Cases	117
Fig. C.6 / Independent Architecture Cases	118
Fig. C.7 / Independent Architecture Shared Situational Awareness	119
TABLES
Table 2.1 Objective and Fitness Measures	14
Table 2.2 Measures of Information Quality	15
Table 3.1 Some Unit Features	22
Table 3.2 Fusion Processing Levels	33
Table 4.1 Exemplar Discrete Awareness Attributes	54
Table 4.2 Exemplar Decision Agents	54
Table 4.3 Attributes Affecting Collaborating Teams	60
Table 4.4 Common Ground Components and Attributes	61
Table B.1 Distribution of Equipment by Unit Type	89
Table B.2 Similarity Matrix for Unit Type	90
Table B.3 Normalized similarity Matrix for Unit Type	91
Table B.4 Network Completeness Assessment	103
Table C.1 Sensor Quality Functions	110




Library of Congress Subject Headings for this publication: Command and control systems United States, Information warfare United States